Hey, you know what’s harder than casting Hazel Grace Lancaster? Casting her superhot, witty, metaphor-loving, martyr-complex-having, cigarette-dangling, defined-jawline-rocking boyfriend, Augustus Waters. This is worse than Finnick, and woe betide the poor boy who gets the role, because that is one impressive shoe he has got to fill. Playing “The Fault in Our Stars”‘ male hero can be a career-maker for a young actor, so in choosing five young people we tried to broaden our view beyond “pretty” to include “soulful” and maybe a little unexpected. One thing became very clear as we hashed this out: opinions will vary widely. We hope you like ours, and we look forward to seeing yours in the comments!